Packing proof · 7 min · 2026-11-07
Order arrived damaged or tampered with: how to claim from the carrier with proof
Dented or opened box: the customer blames the store and the carrier blames the packaging. What proof to request, what to keep and how not to pay twice.
Summary
What matters before moving forward.
- When an order arrives damaged, the store is caught in the middle: the customer wants a fix now, and the carrier only compensates with proof and within the contract deadlines.
- The proof has two parts: the box and item condition at dispatch, which only the store can keep, and the condition on arrival, which only the customer can record.
- Photos of the outside of the box before opening, the label and the damaged item, requested from the customer at first contact, are essential.
- A packing video shows the item left intact and well protected. Without it, the carrier can argue the packaging was inadequate.
- Deadlines to claim from the carrier are short and set in the contract. A late claim is lost even with good proof.
The store in the middle
The customer receives a dented box, opens it and the item is broken. They write to the store, because that is where they bought. From the customer's point of view the problem is the store's, and they are right: the store sold it to them.
The store, in turn, wants to recover the loss from the carrier. The carrier only compensates if there is proof the damage happened in transit and the claim is made within the deadline and contract terms.
Without proof, the store settles with the customer and pays twice: the new item and the broken one.
Proof at dispatch
Only the store can prove how the order left. A packing video shows the item was intact, how it was protected and how the box was closed and labelled.
This point is decisive, because the carrier's most common argument is inadequate packaging. A video showing proper filling and a well sealed box answers that argument.
For fragile items, it is worth having a written packing standard and always following it. The video shows it was followed.
Proof on arrival
Only the customer can record how the order arrived. Ask them at first contact for photos of the outside of the box before opening, if still possible, the shipping label, the inside with the filling and the damaged item.
Also ask them to keep the box and filling for a few days. Some carriers ask to see or collect the packaging.
If the customer has not yet accepted delivery and the box is visibly damaged, they can refuse it or accept with reservation with the courier, depending on the carrier's rules.
Deadlines and contract
Carriers set short deadlines for damage claims and maximum compensation amounts that depend on the service and insurance purchased. Read your contract before you need it.
For valuable items, extra insurance or a declared value service may pay off. Without them, compensation can fall below the item's value.
Log every claim with the date, proof and response. After a few months you know which carrier and service damage most.
Settling with the customer without waiting for the carrier
The customer should not wait for the carrier claim to finish. With the photos and the dispatch video, the store has enough to decide straight away: replace or refund, and claim from the carrier in parallel.
This keeps the customer happy and separates two problems: the customer relationship and recovering the loss.
How Vokzar helps recover damage
We install video packing proof showing item and packaging condition at dispatch, linked to the order number.
We prepare an automatic message to the customer when they report damage, asking for the right photos, and a log of carrier claims.
We help define the packing standard for fragile items and measure damage by carrier and service.
Related next steps
Next steps.
Proof and validation
- Claim deadlines and compensation limits depend on each carrier, service and contract.
- Accepting with reservation or refusing delivery depends on each carrier's rules.
- The customer relationship follows consumer rights, regardless of the carrier claim.
Official documentation
Validated sources.
Technical strategy should be auditable. These sources link directly to the official documentation behind this guide.
Frequently asked questions
Common questions about this topic.
Who is responsible for an order that arrives damaged?
Towards the customer, the store that sold it. The store can then claim from the carrier, if it has proof and within the contract deadlines.
Which photos should I ask the customer for?
The outside of the box, the shipping label, the inside with the filling and the damaged item. Also ask them to keep the box for a few days.
Why do I need proof at dispatch?
Because the carrier's most common argument is inadequate packaging. A packing video shows the item left intact and well protected.
Should I wait for the carrier before settling with the customer?
No. With the proof, the store can replace or refund straight away and claim from the carrier in parallel.

