Automation · 7 min · 2026-11-07

SMS or email for order notifications: when to use each

Email open rates are no longer reliable and SMS is paid per message. A practical map of which notice goes by email, which goes by SMS and which goes by both.

SMSEmailShopify notificationsPost-purchase experienceMail Privacy Protection

Summary

What matters before moving forward.

  • The right question is not which channel is better, it is which notice must be seen within hours and which can be read whenever the customer wants.
  • Email open rates are no longer a reliable measure: Apple Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background whether or not the email is opened.
  • Email is the right channel for documents: invoice, return instructions, order summary. SMS is the right channel for deadlines: payment, pickup, failed delivery.
  • Sending everything on both channels is the most common mistake. It doubles costs, annoys customers and trains them to ignore both messages.
  • To measure, use outcomes: payments completed after the notice, pickups within the deadline and emails asking where the order is.

The problem with comparing channels by opens

For years, SMS and email were compared by open rates. That number no longer means what it seemed to. Since iOS 15, Apple Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote email content in the background whether or not the user opens the email. To the sending system, many emails look opened without ever being read.

With SMS, opens are not measured at all. What can be measured is delivery and, when there is a link, the click.

So comparing the two channels by opens means comparing an inflated number with a number that does not exist. The useful comparison is different: what the customer did after the notice.

The simple rule: deadline or document

Split your notifications into two families. Deadline notices lose value if they are read tomorrow: a Multibanco payment about to expire, an order in a locker with limited days, a failed delivery, an order leaving today for someone who asked for urgency.

Documents are what customers need to keep or check: confirmation with the item summary, invoice, return instructions, warranty, a voucher code. These need space, formatting and attachments, and email does that better and almost for free.

With this split the choice stops being a matter of taste. Deadlines go by SMS, documents go by email.

The map, notice by notice

Order confirmation: email. If the customer bought with a phone number only, a short SMS with the order number and a link to the order page.

Unpaid Multibanco reference: email with the details at checkout, and an SMS reminder before the reference expires. This is the case where both channels work together, because each arrives at a different moment.

Order shipped: email with the details and tracking. SMS only once the carrier records the first scan, so the link does not open an empty page.

Failed delivery or order at a pickup point: SMS, always. The customer has to act within days and the email may go unread.

Invoice and returns: email. An SMS with an attached invoice does not exist, and a link to a PDF by SMS looks like phishing.

Why sending everything on both channels goes wrong

The natural reaction is to send everything by email and SMS to make sure it arrives. In practice the customer gets the same information twice at every step, and from the third order onwards stops reading either message.

There is also the cost. Each SMS is paid and, in Portuguese, each accent such as ç, ã or ó cuts the message from 160 to 70 characters. A sequence of five SMS per order, with accents, can cost more than the margin on a cheap product.

And there is the risk of looking pushy or fraudulent. A customer who receives several SMS with links for every order starts to distrust them, at a time when Banco de Portugal regularly warns about fake messages.

Before choosing: do you have the customer's number?

SMS only works if checkout asks for the phone number and the number is in a usable format. Many stores make the phone optional, and some numbers arrive without a country code, with spaces or belonging to someone else in the household.

Before deciding on channels, check how many orders from the last 30 days have a phone number and how many are in +351 format. If the share is low, the first step is adjusting checkout, not buying SMS credits.

Remember also that a number given for delivery is not, by itself, permission for marketing. Use it for order notices and handle marketing consent separately.

How Vokzar defines your store's channels

We list every notification your store sends today, by email and by SMS, and mark each one as deadline or document.

We switch off duplicates, configure SMS only for deadline notices, rewrite texts to fit one segment and confirm numbers arrive with +351.

Finally, we measure what matters: payments completed after the reminder, orders collected within the deadline and fewer emails asking where the order is.

Related next steps

Next steps.

Proof and validation

  • How Mail Privacy Protection works is described on Apple's official privacy page.
  • SMS character limits are those documented by Twilio for GSM-7 and UCS-2.
  • The channel map is a configuration recommendation and should be adjusted to each store's volume and product type.

Official documentation

Validated sources.

Technical strategy should be auditable. These sources link directly to the official documentation behind this guide.

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about this topic.

Is it better to notify customers by SMS or by email?

It depends on the notice. Deadline notices, such as Multibanco payment, failed delivery or an order in a locker, go by SMS. Documents, such as a detailed confirmation, invoice and returns, go by email.

Why are email open rates unreliable?

Apple Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background whether or not the email is opened, which makes many emails look opened without being read.

Should I send every notification by SMS and by email?

No. It doubles costs and teaches customers to ignore both messages. The useful exception is Multibanco payment: email with the details and an SMS reminder before it expires.

Can I use the delivery phone number for promotions?

Not by itself. SMS marketing needs prior consent or the customer exception in Portuguese Law 41/2004, with an easy opt out in every message. Order notices are one thing and marketing is another.

Want to apply this to your site?

Next step Technical audit